Forum Breastfeeding

Breastfeeding or bottle feeding?

29 replies · page 1 of 2

sietske
You won't get any criticism from me :-) but I do want to try breastfeeding myself.

Replies

Page 1 of 2

  1. Dani #2

    Once again: just ignore that commentary!
    A child gets nothing out of a stressed-out mother anyway.
    Just do what feels right for you and what seems best for your family!

    Love, dani
  2. gerda #3

    Hey Dani,

    That is the exact reason I'm going to bottle-feed. If I breastfeed, I'll turn into such a stressed-out mom and that's the last thing I want.
    I want to enjoy this pregnancy and baby in a way I couldn't with Maya and Julian due to circumstances, and bottle-feeding is a part of that!
  3. * #4

    @Gerda,
    Like you already say in your post, you just have to do whatever feels best for you, and you DO NOT have to justify yourself. Like I wrote earlier, people sometimes want so badly to push their opinion on you and make their opinion yours. But we're human beings capable of thinking for ourselves and not sheep, so you get to decide for yourself what you do.
    Go ahead and bottle-feed, girl, and don't let anyone push you around.

    Love, Ju
    PS I am going to breastfeed though.
  4. * #5

    @Gerda, bottle-feeding for my 1st and breastfeeding for my 2nd, which went completely great. But I can tell you, if this turns into a drama, I'm just switching to the bottle, regardless of what's considered preferred. Blah blah, that's what I think of it, because like you wrote, the formula composition has really improved hugely over the years.

    Love, Ju
  5. Tineke #6

    I intend to breastfeed. But if it doesn't work out or if I really don't feel good about it, I'll switch to bottle-feeding.
  6. Dani #7

    With my first, I kept trying to breastfeed for 5 days. Wasn't allowed out of bed all those days, my milk didn't come in, and I was lying there stressing out......
    Decided to switch to the bottle and the midwife agreed immediately, didn't make a fuss or anything.

    With my boyfriend's ex, they kept nagging that she had to keep trying to breastfeed even though it really wasn't going well either.
    Boyfriend was just like forget this, went out to get formula, and the little guy did fantastic on the bottle.

    So I do want to give it a try, but I'm definitely not making a huge deal out of it. If it doesn't work out, too bad.
    And I tell myself that I'm the one making the decisions this time and nobody else, even if the whole world turns upside down.

    Got to love those hormones haha!!
  7. Olivia-Anna Beekman #8

    Don't worry Gerda!!
    You tried!!! And in your case you clearly feel much better about bottle-feeding.
    So what's the problem then?
    I would try just pumping though!!
    Your baby gets the absolute best nutrition and you can look into each other's eyes.. Wonderful!

    Personally, I've chosen to do everything I can to breastfeed!!
    But my husband does want me to pump a little so I don't have to get out of bed every night.
    Sweet, right!...
  8. wientje #9

    I'm going to try breastfeeding. It gives your baby a lot of antibodies, and apparently it takes a while before a baby can properly build up their own immunity. You also always have food ready and it's much cheaper.
    But if it doesn't work out, then it doesn't. Of course it could also be that I really hate it, and I think I'd stop then too and switch to bottle-feeding.
    A benefit of bottle-feeding, by the way, is that you can keep much better track of whether they're getting enough. There are also more calories in formula, so they need less of it.
    If it doesn't work because of the sucking reflex and things like that, I think I'll try pumping and giving the pumped milk in a bottle. A friend of mine does that. She has great milk production, but her little girl doesn't latch onto the breast. I think that's a lovely, good solution. Baby gets plenty of antibodies, and they can easily keep track of whether she's drinking enough. Great combo!
  9. Cin #10

    With my son, I tried breastfeeding. He actually drank quite well.. but I don't have the patience for it, had to use a nipple shield etc. It only made me feel stressed out..
    Switched to bottle-feeding, that went great!
    With my daughter, I didn't even try and started bottle-feeding right away..
    Like you said yourself, 2 completely healthy kids here too.
    Now pregnant with baby number 3 and this time I'm also going to bottle-feed right away.
  10. liena #11

    What is actually better anyway?
    Breastfeeding is good because it has lots of antibodies.
    But....
    You aren't allowed to put expressed milk in the microwave because then it heats up too quickly and the antibodies get destroyed :s
    Also, if you breastfeed you have to give extra vitamin K on top of it.
    I breastfeed and give expressed milk in a bottle, and every time I have to give him those nasty oily vitamins on a teaspoon. He really doesn't like that.
    With formula, the vitamins are already in it.
    Today I gave formula for the first time, Nutrilon, which you can combine with breastfeeding. It feels like I suddenly have a completely different baby. Less crying/screaming. And he falls asleep nice and fast again. If he keeps responding this well to it, then I'll quickly switch over to bottle-feeding too.
  11. Shana #12

    I would breastfeed, of course it's everyone's own choice what they do. My guy also already asked me to pump then so he can give a bottle at night for my rest, so that'll all work out fine. Pumping is so easy and yet you're basically giving a bottle hehe. My sister always did it that way too and she had no complaints either
  12. jessie #13

    I am also
  13. Diana #14

    Just both. Doesn't hurt.
  14. katrien #15

    Is it also recommended to combine the two? For example, I'd like to breastfeed in the morning and as often as possible during the day, and maybe a bottle in between. Breastfeed again in the evening, or is this not recommended?
  15. elsie Guest #16

    Keep in mind that if you skip feeds, your supply can drop unless you pump at that moment. Usually your supply is only stable enough after a few months to combine breastfeeding and formula without a drop in production.
  16. karin Guest #17

    I very consciously chose breastfeeding myself, I and my 3 brothers were also raised on breast milk.
    For me it's also a logical choice, I feel that something natural and factory-made isn't even up for debate, naturally something pure nature from Mother Nature is always better and tailored to your baby. But okay, if you have no breast milk, no milk, which can happen, then it's wonderful that formula exists, but I think it's a completely different story if you do have milk, breast milk, but choose formula because you find it tiring, that seems a bit selfish to me.
    And also very unfair to your baby.
    You can never redo that short period, their health is in your hands then, and if you choose formula just because you find breastfeeding a hassle, I find that comes across as very selfish toward your baby. I have twins and breastfeed them, very exhausting and tough, especially the nights, but it's nice and healthy for them and also important for the bond with your baby.
    I just have to put myself aside for my babies during these first few months, after all, that's what being a mother is for.
    Not putting anyone down, that's just my opinion when it comes to breastfeeding.
    Love, Karin
  17. Relaxte borstvoedende moeder Guest #18

    I really enjoy breastfeeding! In my opinion it's actually very relaxing and not stressful at all. Actually easy and not difficult...

    Read this, it's funny!
  18. Luna Guest #19

    Formula is great nutrition.
    You really can't tell by looking at a baby or child whether they were breastfed or bottle-fed. Hormones make us feel guilty. It's also a shame that only breastfeeding gets promoted, because that is very frustrating for women who can't or don't want to breastfeed. Your child isn't happy if you're a pumping, frustrated mother.
    Bottle-feeding is also nice for the dad, other family members can help, it's relaxed, cozy, you know exactly how much a child is getting, it saves time, and it's healthy.
    So just go for bottle-feeding!
  19. Anonymous Guest #20

    Well, a happy mother is a happy baby. Whether you give the bottle or the breast. I breastfeed myself, but I did notice that good guidance in the beginning is very important. In the beginning, my milk didn't come in fast enough. On the midwife's advice, my little one had top-ups after every feed for 1 day, and that day I had to pump after every feed to stimulate production. Whatever I pumped, I could subtract from the top-up, and after 1 day it was going so well that the top-ups could stop because my baby was gaining weight again instead of losing it. It did make me a bit insecure at first about her weight and whether she was getting enough, because you can't see if she's gaining. But had good support with that too, so that fear eased off. Luckily she's growing well, so I'm happy. If it had to be formula, I would've been happy too, as long as my little sprout is doing well. But glad breastfeeding worked out, saves on costs

Add your reply

Share what helped you, or ask a question.

Sign in to join the conversation.

Continue with Google

Takes a moment. You’ll come straight back here to reply.