Forum Breastfeeding

Not wanting to breastfeed

10 replies

SofieGuest ·
I'm 30 weeks pregnant now and I decided early in my pregnancy that I don't want to breastfeed. I don't feel comfortable with the idea, and I think babies do just fine on formula too. Still, I'm getting a lot of negative reactions from the people around me, which is making me doubt myself again. What do you think of my choice?

Replies

  1. nienke Guest #2

    That's totally fine! It's your choice! You have to feel good about it, and if you don't want to do it but do it anyway, it probably won't have much chance of working out. It takes some effort before breastfeeding gets going properly and you and your baby have found a rhythm.

    Of course breastfeeding is very good for your baby, but formula is too! Both my boys only had formula, and they're two healthy boys. For me, breastfeeding didn't get going (probably with the oldest because the placenta didn't come loose by itself after the birth).

    And I honestly didn't feel like doing all the feedings myself, day and night.

    Make it your own choice, together with your partner! By the way, with the second one, my two maternity nurses completely agreed that I didn't start. It was my choice.
  2. Djoke Guest #3

    I think you should do what feels right for you. I'm pro-breastfeeding, but as a postpartum expert I'm even more pro peace and a happy mom. Do what feels good and don't apologize.
  3. Robyn #4

    Hey Sofie,

    Congratulations on your pregnancy. I agree with the previous replies.
    Breastfeeding is indeed the best for your baby, but they'll grow up just fine on formula too.
    My first grew up on formula because of a failed attempt at breastfeeding.
    I had a huge amount of regret that I hadn't pushed through with breastfeeding, so with my second I wanted to breastfeed at all costs. And after lots of ups and downs, it worked out.
    But I also have to be honest: it really takes some work to make breastfeeding succeed, while formula is definitely simpler.
    Do what you feel good about and don't pay any attention to those comments. Your baby, your choice.
    Good luck with the birth!
  4. Cin #5

    I think you shouldn't let it get to you and just do what you feel good about!
    This never works, these are always endless discussions, unfortunately..
    I really didn't want to with my first either, but he was so tiny and it wasn't going well, so I gave it a try. After 3 weeks I started cutting back and switched to the bottle anyway...
    I had no patience for it, and I also had to use a nipple shield, which made me a nervous wreck, and that's not good for your baby either...
    With the 2nd and now the 3rd too, it was straight to formula... And they grow great on it too ;-)
  5. Olivia-Anna #6

    It's indeed your own choice!
    It's been your baby for 9 months already and you have to do what feels right for yourself..

    The only advice I'd give you is:
    Try it just once..
    Put them to the breast once when there's nobody around who could interfere.
    Maybe you'll change your mind when you see your baby's loving reaction and your body's reaction to it.
    I do it and I've never felt anything so beautiful!! You don't just see it, you experience it..
    Personally, I can't do without it anymore!!
    I think it's a privilege that only the mother gets to enjoy, and that feeling is blissful and unique..

    But good luck with whatever you choose!!
  6. Evelyn Guest #7

    I'm very pro-breastfeeding, but at the same time I think it's better to lovingly give the bottle than to give the breast against your will. Your baby will definitely feel your motherly love! So just follow your gut...
  7. Veronique Guest #8

    Hi Sofie,

    I just hope you make a truly well-informed choice. Because if you say you think babies "do fine too" on formula, I wonder whether you've really looked into the differences properly.

    Just know that formula-fed babies get sick more often in the first year, have more ear infections, more respiratory infections, more diarrhea, colic, constipation, stomach/intestinal infections or urinary tract infections. They also have more allergic symptoms. In the long term, formula-fed babies have a higher risk of obesity, childhood cancer, juvenile diabetes and food sensitivity. All of this has been scientifically proven.

    Of course formula contains all the fats, proteins and carbohydrates your baby needs. On top of that, a few vitamins are added. So yes, they will grow up on it. But it also gives a higher chance of all the conditions mentioned above.
  8. mamavan2 Guest #9

    Hello Veronique,

    All I can say in response is that I understand someone wanting to give formula. I gave my daughter formula too. For the first two years she wasn't sick at all. She's three now and has only had a few colds. So be careful with your comment, because you could make another mom-to-be feel bad about herself.
    You should look up the research on the difference between hypoallergenic formula and breast milk, just for fun.
  9. Veronique Guest #10

    Hi mamavan2,

    I can certainly understand it too if someone wants to give formula. But what I can't understand is that people think formula and breast milk are about the same and don't bother to look into it. And I'm glad you have such healthy kids, but it's a fact that the CHANCE of them getting sick is higher. That doesn't mean they actually will get sick. It means there's simply a higher chance of it.

    And I don't think it's fair that it's my fault if someone feels guilty because I say what has been scientifically proven. Make your choice based on the right information and stand by it. You could, for example, click this link and read everything the Nutrition Centre says about breast milk.
    http://http://www.voedingscentrum.nl/encyclopedie/moedermelk.aspx#blok3

    I'd love to read that research on hypoallergenic formula (which is still made from the same cow's milk, by the way) and breast milk. Do you know where I can find it? (When I google it I find nothing.)
  10. pvoorneveld #11

    Hi!
    My little one is now 1 week old.. breastfeeding is super easy and really lovely to do. It's truly amazing to see what these tiny babies can do and "know" about their own feeding.
    They figure out how often they eat on their own, and that's pretty awesome!
    I think everyone should decide for themselves whether they want to breastfeed or not..but I think it's really great!

Add your reply

Share what helped you, or ask a question.

Sign in to join the conversation.

Continue with Google

Takes a moment. You’ll come straight back here to reply.