Forum Parenting

Punishing and rewarding (Help request)

1 reply

RJB
How do I ask my 21-month-old son the reason for his behavior?
When he does something he's not allowed to, I warn him. If he does it again, I put him in the hallway for 1.5 minutes. Afterwards I tell him why I did that and I give him a cuddle. Now when he does something he's not allowed to and I say that if he does it again he'll go to the hallway, he often already stops.....
Sorry, but I think if you give kids no consequences they become annoying kids. I haven't become any less of a person because of it. So I use the Jo Frost method and I believe in it completely.

Also...I reward my son when he behaves in the supermarket, for example. If he doesn't behave there I ignore his behavior and I don't reward him. Again I explain it to him every time. I'm not going to put him in a hallway in the supermarket, which is why I handle it like that there.
I also hug him to pieces .. because I love him like crazy! Good for bonding and self-esteem.
A child sometimes needs a firm hand... that will differ per child....

Replies

  1. m&j Guest #2

    I agree with Steven and Tischa. I (almost) never punished my kids, at least not when they were very little. Punishment violates a child's trust in their caregiver. It's also quite an intense reaction from an adult, seen through a child's eyes, just like a child being praised to the skies for doing a simple task. Approval or disapproval already comes across enough to a child.

Add your reply

Share what helped you, or ask a question.

Sign in to join the conversation.

Continue with Google

Takes a moment. You’ll come straight back here to reply.