Grandparents favoring one grandchild over another

Grandparent favoritism is common, and it usually comes down to childcare, distance or which side of the family you're on, not your child. You can raise it once, change how visits go, or stop chasing.

A grandmother hands a wrapped present to her granddaughter while a younger boy stands back with empty hands, watching.

You saw it at the last visit, or in another photo of the cousins' sleepover: Grandma (nan) lights up for one grandchild and barely notices yours. Or she dotes on one of your kids and overlooks the other. It hurts, then the second-guessing starts. Am I keeping score? Am I being petty?

You're not imagining it, and plenty of families deal with this. The reason usually has little to do with your child. And you have three real options: say something once, change how visits run, or stop chasing.

Is it just me?

Far from it. In a big US poll, roughly 1 in 5 parents who'd disagreed with a grandparent said it was over treating some grandkids differently. It tends to show in the same places: the presents, whose photos are on the walls and on Grandma's social media, who gets the sleepovers and the school pickups.

Why would a grandparent have a favorite?

Mostly, it comes down to time. One in 4 US kids under 5 has a grandparent looking after them while their parents work or go to school. A grandma who does pickups twice a week builds a bond that monthly visits or a flight away can't match.

The side of the family counts as well. Teens in England and Wales got the most time and support from their mother's mom, and less from their dad's parents. Your mother-in-law might be easygoing with her daughter's children and more hesitant with yours, sometimes for fear of overstepping.

Or it's the first grandchild, the long-hoped-for girl or boy, the kid who just clicks. Age plays a part too. A baby of 8 to 12 months can go through stranger anxiety and cling to you when Grandpa reaches for her, while her chatty 4-year-old brother races into his arms. It's a normal phase, and it fades. Grandparents often don't see they have a favorite.

Seeing the cousins more because they live down the road is logistics. A forgotten birthday, a gift for one child and none for the other, a whole visit spent on the cousins: that's effort. And effort is something you can ask for.

What if it's between your own kids?

Here it's your turf. Steer the grandparent toward whichever child is getting less: when people come to meet the baby, ask them to play with your older one, or pass the baby to Grandma while you head outside with the preschooler. Praise the overlooked child where visitors can hear. If presents are lopsided, a quiet word before the next birthday lands better than a scene on the day. More on splitting your attention in two under two.

Should you say something, and who should?

With your partner's parents, your partner is usually the one to bring it up. With your own mom, or if you're parenting solo, it's yours to say. Lots of partners brush it off ("Mom's just like that"), and then you two need to agree first (see arguing with your partner after baby).

Bring it up once, in private, and keep it about your child, not a scorecard. Cool off first, hear them out, and leave old fights alone. You might try: "He wanted to know why you always pick up his cousins but never him. Could you take him for an afternoon? He'd be thrilled."

Parents in that poll who asked a grandparent to change something (any issue, not just this one) got mixed results: about half saw things change, a third got a yes and then nothing different, and around 1 in 6 were told no outright.

Keeping quiet is a real choice too, when it's distance or a phase, or the conversation would cost more than it could win.

What do you tell your child?

Many parents find kids catch on once they're old enough to compare gifts and pickups. There's no need to tell them they've got it wrong, or to run Grandma down. Say what they noticed, give the simple reason if there is one, then bring it back to the two of you: "You've noticed Grandma spends a lot of time with your cousins. That can feel unfair. She lives close to them and helps out after school. I love hanging out with you. What do you want to do on Saturday?"

When is it okay to stop trying?

When you've asked and nothing changed. Pulling back can be quiet: match the effort they put in, open presents at home rather than next to the cousins, visit when it suits you, and spend your energy on the adults who do show up. About 15% of US parents limit how much time their child spends with certain grandparents.

Parents who step back often say the hurt eased, even though the grandparent stayed just as close to the other grandkids. Cutting contact is a bigger move: your child can lose cousins and aunts along with the grandparent, and some families feel that's too much over favoritism alone.

Going through this right now?Talk to other parents in our Motherhood forum

Sources

C.S. Mott Children's Hospital (University of Michigan): When parents and grandparents disagree. ZERO TO THREE: Grandparent Films: Sharing Child Care Between Generations. Biology Letters 2023: Tanskanen et al.: Differential grandparental investment when maternal grandmothers are living versus deceased. HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Tips for Grandparents of 8 to 12-Month-Old, Preparing Your Older Child for a New Baby: How to Help Siblings Adjust. HSE (Ireland): Preparing older children for a new sibling. Better Health Channel (Victoria): Family conflict.