Hey Bear and Ms. Rachel: are sensory videos OK for babies?

Baby in a high chair watching bright shapes on a tablet while her mother cooks dinner in the background

Screen-time guidelines say babies are better off without videos of any kind, Hey Bear and Ms. Rachel included: none before 18 months in the US, none before 2 in most other countries. Video calls with family are the one exception. The reason is how little babies learn from a screen. A short clip has never been shown to harm them. Research linking screens with slower speech looks at an hour or more a day; no study can tell you whether 10 minutes while you shower matters.

If you already use some screen time, you have plenty of company: across the world, only about one in four children under 2 get none. And these two favorites are far from the same kind of show.

Two very different shows

Hey Bear Sensory moves fast. Brightly colored fruit and shapes bop across a black screen to upbeat music, with no talking. No one has tested these videos on babies, so promises about training a baby's eyes or brain are a sales line. What's known about pace comes from 4-year-olds, who did worse on self-control tasks after 9 minutes of a fast cartoon than after a slower show.

Ms. Rachel takes her time. She talks in a sing-song voice, asks a question, then waits for an answer, and she uses simple signs. There's no published research on her videos either, but her format has what helps young children learn from video: clear goals, no distracting effects, pauses for an answer and parents invited to join in.

Either way, babies under about 18 months learn words from people who react to them, and a recording can't. In one US study, 12- to 18-month-olds who watched a baby vocabulary DVD for a month learned no more words than children who didn't. That's why video calls count: grandma on FaceTime talks back. From around 15 months, the difference comes from you watching along and using the words and signs, on screen and off.

Why does the US say 18 months and other countries 2 years?

In the US, the AAP draws its line at 18 months. For a younger baby who does watch, it suggests short educational shows, watched together. The WHO and health authorities in Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Ireland go further: no screen time before 2. UK guidance is looser: local health services say children under 2 don't need screen time, and UK pediatricians set no age limit, because the evidence is too thin.

What the research means if you already use them

On speech, a study of about 7,000 children in Japan found that one-year-olds with 1 to 2 hours of screens a day had about 1.6 times the odds of a communication delay on a screening at age 2, and the odds climbed with more hours. Its lowest group was "under 1 hour", so it can't compare 10 minutes with none.

Fears about autism come from studies such as one of 84,000 Japanese children: boys who had an hour or more of screens a day at age 1 were diagnosed with autism more often by 3. Below an hour there was no clear link, and in girls there was none. The researchers couldn't rule out the reverse: babies with early signs of autism may be more drawn to screens. The idea that TV causes ADHD goes back to a 2004 US study whose link didn't hold up when the data were reanalyzed.

If your baby's talking worries you, bring it up at the next checkup (in the UK, with your health visitor). Most children try at least three words other than names for their parents by 18 months. Our article on late talkers has more.

Cutting the downside

If a video gets you through a shower or dinner prep, autoplay off keeps it to one. Ads play on 95% of early-childhood videos on YouTube; downloaded or ad-free versions skip them. It helps when a video isn't the only thing that soothes your baby, and when screens are off for the hour before bed.

Phones and tablets stay out of the crib. While you're in the shower, a crib, play yard or bouncer on the floor is the place for your baby, never a bed, sofa or countertop. In the car, nothing goes on the car seat that didn't come with it, so no clip-on tablet holders; music or a soft toy can fill the gap.

Background TV counts too. In lab studies, young children hardly glanced at an adult program playing in the room, yet their play came in shorter bursts and their parents talked to them less. With two under two, you could turn the baby's play mat away from the screen or save the toddler's show for the baby's nap.

Skipping them, or taking a break

Not starting is a good option, and often the easiest in the first months. Your face, a play gym and high-contrast board books are the live version of a sensory video. Having your baby in the bathroom with you, or music while you cook, covers most of the moments a video would (more on showering when you're home alone with a baby). If videos seem to leave your baby wired or harder to settle, try a few days without.

Baby on a play mat under a play gym while her mother shows her a black-and-white board book, the TV switched off
Going through this right now?Talk to other parents in our Babies (0 to 2) forum

Sources

HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Kids & Screen Time: The 5 C's Questions to Ask for Infants, Helping Kids Thrive in a Digital World: AAP Policy Explained, How to Keep Your Sleeping Baby Safe: AAP Policy Explained, Healthy Sleep Habits: How Many Hours Does Your Child Need?, Car Seats: Information for Families, Tips for Safe & Stress-Free Family Travel. American Academy of Pediatrics: Watching Ms. Rachel: How To Advise Parents of Infants and Toddlers. WHO: To grow up healthy, children need to sit less and play more. Caring for Kids (Canadian Paediatric Society): Screen use and young children. Sydney Children's Hospitals Network: Screen time recommendations for toddlers 1-3 years. Plunket (New Zealand): Play and learning: one to two years. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021: Associations between Home Environment, Children's and Parents' Characteristics and Children's TV Screen Time Behavior. Public Health in Practice 2025: Digital screen exposure in infants, children and adolescents: a systematic review of existing recommendations. Bedfordshire and Luton Children's Health Services (NHS): Screen time. JAMA Pediatrics 2022: McArthur et al.: Global Prevalence of Meeting Screen Time Guidelines Among Children 5 Years and Younger: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis, Kushima et al.: Association Between Screen Time Exposure in Children at 1 Year of Age and Autism Spectrum Disorder at 3 Years of Age: The Japan Environment and Children's Study. Pediatrics 2011: Lillard and Peterson: The immediate impact of different types of television on young children's executive function. Psychological Science 2010: DeLoache et al.: Do babies learn from baby media? Child Development 2014: Roseberry et al.: Skype me! Socially contingent interactions help toddlers learn language. JAMA Pediatrics 2023: Takahashi et al.: Screen Time at Age 1 Year and Communication and Problem-Solving Developmental Delay at 2 and 4 Years. Pediatrics 2004: Christakis et al.: Early television exposure and subsequent attentional problems in children. Child Development 2010: Foster and Watkins: The value of reanalysis: TV viewing and attention problems. CDC: Milestones by 18 Months. Child Development 2008: Schmidt et al.: The effects of background television on the toy play behavior of very young children. Child Development 2009: Kirkorian et al.: The impact of background television on parent-child interaction. NHS: Baby and toddler safety.