Forum Nice chat

Time-out corner isn't a nice way to teach your baby something.

11 replies

madelene
I recently saw a discussion on TV where a parenting psychologist explained that she didn't approve of the "naughty corner" method of discipline, finding it too distant and cold. She said that instead of learning, children tend to get frustrated and perceive their parents as distant and cold. I watched in amazement because I happened to agree with her. I also don't like that way of dealing with my toddlers. She mentioned in that program that...

Replies

  1. madelene started this #2

    I'd rather do it with my toddler than not, because she has kids of her own too, so she's just there to help when they have a tantrum, hold them, and say, "Mommy still loves you, calm down, why are you so angry, sweetheart?"
    So instead of punishing them in a corner, you help your child out of their tantrum.
    And instead of saying "you're annoying," you say "you're doing something annoying," so the child knows that you love them but just find their behavior annoying.
    Now I was wondering, are there more mothers who prefer not to use this approach?
    Greetings, Madelene
  2. Faile #3

    The doc has something to say for both of them. Later on, when they're older, they won't always be treated gently by the outside world either. I think it helps them understand that what they do has consequences. As long as you lay it out briefly to the child and then talk about it a bit, I don't think there's much to worry about.
  3. madelene started this #4

    Hi Faile,
    Yeah, that's true for both. Maybe it's a bit extreme to say, but I think the method is good for people who hit their kids. It's better for them to do it this way instead of hitting, and I think that's good for such people.
  4. madelene started this #5

    For parents who, for example, tend to hit quickly and struggle to control themselves, and don't know how to communicate with their young children, so they resort to hitting—such parents might find the "time out" or "naughty step" method helpful.
    But personally, I don't like it; I find it a distant way of interacting with your child.
  5. Faile #6

    Well, I'm also in favor of the disciplinary smack (one smack, not hitting). I had it myself growing up and honestly, it didn't leave me with any negative effects But yeah, there are arguments on both sides, haha.
  6. Muus86 #7

    Nice to take a look at it once in a while; unconditional parenting. This method is based on a positive approach (so also not letting them cry and all that). I'm not saying it's completely feasible, but it's interesting!
  7. madelene started this #8

    Hi Faile, I hadn't finished my message yet haha, I thought I'd make some tea. Thanks for your quick reply.

    I don't think it's necessary to prepare my kids for the fact that life can be hard later on. I spoil my little ones while I can, now that they're small. Soon enough they'll have plenty of worries and responsibilities, so that's why I want them to enjoy being kids now. So that later they can look back on a loving, warm childhood where they weren't punished but had space to talk.

    My eldest daughter, who's 5, is also allowed to just give her opinion. For example, if she says, "Mum, you don't look good like that," I don't say, "How rude, you're not allowed to say that." Instead, I say, "Thank you, Yara, for your honest answer. It's very good that you're honest with Mum."

    I think it's important for children to learn to form their own opinions and to be themselves, to a certain extent, of course. But I see that a lot of parents don't appreciate this and actually unconsciously hold back a child's pure honesty.

    Anyway, I'm drifting off, let me just stop there.
  8. madelene started this #9

    Sorry for all the messages, my phone's been acting up. I always talk to my girls and never use spanking; I explain everything why I don't want something. I never say "you're annoying" because, even if it sounds crazy or far-fetched, a child (especially a toddler) absorbs everything, and unconsciously they literally start to feel like an annoying person and think their parent finds them annoying as a person. So I always say "you're being annoying right now." Then I make it clear that I don't want that behavior from her at that moment, but I do love her as a person; I only disapprove of her behavior at that moment. So I only find her annoying for that moment. Anyway, we never used spanking at home either. I guess I picked that up from my family. I respect how others parent; everyone does it their own way. But personally, I prefer doing it this way. It's nice to share with other ladies and mothers. Greetings, Madelene
  9. madelene started this #10

    Hi Muus, that's exactly what I mean by approaching things positively and definitely not letting them cry. I know what you mean, that's more my parenting style. Greetings, Madelene
  10. - #11

    I’ve also heard that you should cuddle them in those situations. But when my son has a tantrum and I come over to calm him down or something, he just gets really worked up and even angrier. If I just leave him alone for a moment, it’s over within a few seconds. So I don’t put him in a timeout corner or chair or anything. I just ignore it, and when he’s done, I ask if everything’s okay, and often he comes to give me a hug himself. I think every child is different, and you should adjust your parenting style accordingly! Love
  11. madelene started this #12

    Hi Manon, what you describe, I can relate to with some kids. Sometimes it's better to just leave them alone and ignore them.

    I do that sometimes with my oldest when she has a tantrum because she's tired, for example. Then I just leave her for a bit. She says, "Mama, you're not nice, I'm so mad at you," and she's in a bad mood.

    Then I usually say, "Yes, but Mama thinks you're so sweet." Then she goes to her room, closes the door, angry, and I just let her calm down on her own. She always comes back on her own.

    But I also know that I get those comments directed at me because she's tired and I don't understand her quickly enough.

Add your reply

Share what helped you, or ask a question.

Sign in to join the conversation.

Continue with Google

Takes a moment. You’ll come straight back here to reply.